Row Wrapper 2

LOST SHAKER OF SALT ~ Relax!

4.9200
(75 Reviews)

Capacity

3 Bedrooms
2 Bath
Sleeps 8

Search Availability

About

THE HEART OF OLD TOWN...
Charming Old Town home in the heart of Key West.  Located on Southard Street just steps from Duval's many restaurants and bars. You are in walking distance to museums, shopping, and Fort Zachary Taylor beach.  Relax on the front porch and watch the people walk by while sipping a cocktail or reading a book.
***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE

SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS AND FURNISHINGS...
This home has a beautiful, large master suite with king size bed just off the front porch with an adjoining spacious bath that offers a shower and a hanging closet.  Although the room is surrounded by windows that fills the room with soft, natural light, there are also blinds that offer privacy and shade for guests. There is a flat screen and dresser for your convenience. Youtube TV service is available in this home.

Walk up the spiral staircase to find 2 twins beds in a quiet loft, that can convert to a king, overlooking the kitchen and sitting area which has a pull out couch for two additional guests.  The updated private guest bathroom is located just off the renovated kitchen and has a glass tile shower. The kitchen is fully equipped for meal preparation and serving and has a breakfast bar for 2, stainless steel appliances, and custom cabinetry.  The guest room has a queen size bed with a hanging closet, luggage rack, flat screen and a dresser. 

POOL AND OUTDOOR LIVING...
French doors open to the private 40' heated pool with a back deck and four lounge chairs where you can spend the day in peace and quiet under the tropical landscaping. The back deck also has a grill and table that are ideal for dining Al Fresco.  Your best friend can enjoy the fully fenced yard in this pet friendly home as well.

PARKING...
This home does not have designated parking but there is on street parking in the surrounding neighborhood.  Please refrain from parking in spots marked “residential”. Guests may also park at the Old Town Parking Garage which allows daily and monthly rates.

Simonton Beach is 0.16 mi.
Fort Zachary Taylor Beach is 1.1 mi.
South Beach is 0.8 mi.
Higgs Beach is 1.2 mi.
Smathers Beach is 2.3 mi.

CONCIERGE SERVICES...
Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip, from bike/scooter/golf cart rentals to any excursion you can think of including snorkeling and sunset cruises, jet ski rentals, parasailing, kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding and much more. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival!

LIVE LIKE A LOCAL!

Features

Amenities

  • Free Wifi
  • Coffee Maker
  • Dishwasher
  • Kitchen
  • Microwave
  • Oven
  • Refrigerator
  • Stove
  • Toaster
  • Heated Pool
  • Private Pool
  • Street parking
  • Central Air
  • Washer & Dryer
  • Gas Grill

Rental Type and Location

  • House
  • Old Town
  • Best of Key West Rentals
  • Key West
  • Key West, FL

Pet Friendly

  • Yes

Duration

  • Nightly

Availability

Key
#Night Available#Night Unavailable#Arrive Only#Depart Only
December 2024
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
January 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
February 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
 
March 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
April 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
August 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
September 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
October 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
November 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 

Map

Reviews

Leave a Review

Lost Shaker of Salt part 2

November 2024
, Elk Grove Village, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Staying at the Lost Shaker of Salt again did not disappoint. Can’t beat the location. Two short blocks from Duval St. The accommodations met our needs for a group of five. The pool is a definite plus. Communicating with the management team was great. Can’t wait until our next trip to Key West and staying at Lost Shaker of Salt part 3.

Great House and Location!

October 2024
, Palm Bay, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a really nice and comfortable stay in this house. It's well decorated and well appointed. Comfortable sofa and chair in the living room, large primary bedroom with extra large bathroom. Nice size 2nd bedroom and 2nd shower. We didn't use the 2nd floor 3 Rd bedroom. It had a neat spiral staircase going up to it. The ceilings up there are low, but for kids or shorter people it would be fine, plus how much time do you spend just sitting in your bedroom when you could be out exploring Key West?!! The kitchen was nice and had everything we needed. The pool and landscaping are nice and well cared for. We were very happy and comfortable here. It was just me and my husband but we like having our own bathrooms and space. Plus some friends came by one evening and we had plenty of room to visit and have drinks with them.

Great house

October 2024
, Blue Bell, PA Unknown

Overall
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We enjoyed our stay! Property manager was very helpful. House was clean and very comfortable. Loved the outside area and the pool!! Location to Duval Street and local restaurants good

Great location!

September 2024
, Auburndale, FL US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

This home was a perfect location for our family trip. Loved having the pool to come back and cool off!

Great Home!

August 2024
, Orange beach, AL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This house was perfect for us! Our group consisted of 2 couples. We love to walk everywhere so the location was ideal. Visiting KW over Labor Day weekend was HOT...the pool was divine! The home was comfortable and we had everything we needed. It was great for 2 couples...3 would have been crowded as the loft is very small and open air to the living area. For us, we loved it and we will return!

Slice of Heaven

August 2024
, Seattle, WA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This house is a Key West dream. I can't imagine our trip without staying at this place. So lovely and clean with an easy walk to so much. All the finishes in the house are so thoughtful with a lot of attention paid to the guest's experience. We will be back.

Great Trip to Key West!

August 2024
, Raleigh, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The location and house in general was fantastic. Very quite location but short stroll to Duval. Easily slept 2 couples very comfortably and the pool was really nice. Very happy with the cleanliness and the communication from the management company. Couldn't ask for a better experience! Will look to stay here again for future trips!

Fantastic property in a great position

July 2024
, Cowden, GB

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This is fabulous property - roomy and clean, with a lovely pool - in a great position: close to the action but far enough away to be quiet and restful.

Great House and Great Location

July 2024
, Cornelius, NC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Great house with a nice pool and all amenities needed. We used the grill and pool everyday. One block from king street and plenty of on street parking. A/C had a hard time keeping up but it was the middle of July so kind of expected. We would definitely stay here again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Chip. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Great House and Great Location

July 2024
, Cornelius, NC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Great house with a nice pool and all amenities needed. We used the grill and pool everyday. One block from king street and plenty of on street parking. A/C had a hard time keeping up but it was the middle of July so kind of expected. We would definitely stay here again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Chip. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Perfect getaway!!

July 2024
, Metairie, LA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect experience from start to finish.
Excellent communication regarding arrival and departure instructions.
Prompt answering of all of our questions.
Helpful with any concerns and suggestive responses (i.e, where do we park?!?)
Super neat and clean.
Left a light on for our late arrival!
Location was 5 minute golf cart drive to anywhere on the island!
Super professional company to deal with.
Could not have asked for a better experience!!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your incredible review Leland! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Great stay

June 2024
, Oak Island , NC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Fantastic house. Great service.

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us! We would love to welcome you back!

Best, Most Cozy Home

May 2024
, Boca Raton, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was beautiful and peaceful. Great environment. Just parked in the lot and called it a day. Many Residential Parking spaces, but we rented a golf cart. Can't wait to come back!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Marc! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and can't wait to welcome you back!

Long Weekend Trip

April 2024
, Darien Center, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
4
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Overall, it was a good experience. However, the sofa bed had not been made up and we couldn't find the sheets the night we arrived. We also had to call to get the code to enter as our daughters arrived at 4:00and they had not provided it yet.

Manager's Response

Carol thank you for taking the time to review your stay, we are thrilled you enjoyed this home! The code is sent right at check in time unless we are able to accomodate an early check in but our cleaning team works hard to make each unit squeaky clean before our guests arrive, sometimes they need until the very last minute to make it perfect. We are so sorry you couldn't find the sheets, looking upon the notes, it doesn't look like you let us know you needed the sleeper couch. In any case, please reach out to your property manager as soon as you come upon an issue, they will fix anything humanly possible! We really hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island, thank you for being our guest!

Just what we needed

March 2024
, EDMOND, OK US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a wonderful stay here.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Great location!

February 2024
, Leawood, KS United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Wonderful time visiting Key West! House was clean and comfy. Check in was easy, nice pool, great customer service.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Perfect Key West Cottage

January 2024
, Huntsville, AL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Excellent stay at Lost Shaker of Salt! Favorite Key West Location. Really enjoyed the pool and porches. Wonderful property manager, Shana. Would definitely stay again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

New Year 2024

December 2023
, Adamsville, TN Unknown

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Everything was great! No issues with the house or anything in it. Location was great!

Manager's Response

We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West David. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Great Place to stay!

November 2023
, Hixson, TN United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Place was clean and great location. We were able to walk to most places. Close to Duval, but far enough is was not loud at night. Owners were very helpful! Would def stay there again! A+++

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Mark. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Just what we needed!

August 2023
, Melbournw, FL Unknown

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This was a last minute booking for us and Shana our property manager was awesome. The property was just what me and my husband needed. Plenty of linens and supplies. Home was very clean. Pool was great, especially after a long day of adventures before you head back out for a late dinner. If you’re familiar with Key West then you’ll agree this location is perfect. Beach days at Ft Zachary (buy a state park pass if you’re a fl resident), Duval is at your doorstep without the noise, restaurants galore. Parking wasn’t an issue for us, we walked almost everywhere. It was good to come back after a long hiatus from Key West and we’ll come back to Lost Shaker of Salt!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your incredible review Jojo! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Amazing key home

August 2023
, Pembroke Pines, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Clean, great location house was fantastic recommending that you book this home. Definitely going back

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Thomas. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Could not have asked for better in Key West!

July 2023
, Saint Petersburg, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The rental was booked last minute and every part of the booking experience was handled promptly and with extreme kindness. The rental home was extremely clean, well stocked, beautiful private pool, and very close to it all. We definitely will be back!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Joel! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Lost Shaker of Salt

July 2023
, Port Orange, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

This place was perfect! Great location, helpful concierge, clean and nice! We will be back!!!

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Shannon! We would love to welcome you back!

Blocks From Duval and Seaport

July 2023
, Boca Raton, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
5

This is a great home with a cozy feel. The house has all the Key West charm you need with an amazing location next to the Seaport and Duval. The beds were cozy and comfortable. The pool was the perfect temperature. We will be back!

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Nadine! We would love to welcome you back!

Great House near Duval

April 2023
, Winchester, MA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Very nice house, location can't be beat. The pool was great for hanging out in the late afternoon, between activities and going out to Dinners / Happy Hours. House was exactly as advertised. Management company was very easy to deal with.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review James, we are so glad the property met your needs while staying with us. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit Key West.

Clean, Convenient, Great Pool

February 2023
, Succasunna, NJ United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

Great location but busy street if you are a light sleeper.
Pool is spacious with mix of sun and shade.

Manager's Response

We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West Allyson. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Clean, Convenient, Great Pool

February 2023
, Succasunna, NJ US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

Great location but busy street if you are a light sleeper.
Pool is spacious with mix of sun and shade.

Manager's Response

We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West Allyson. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Fun filled relaxing weekend

February 2023
, Hartland, WI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The property management communicated great with us. We got all the information we needed before, during and after the trip. Home was clean. The location is close enough to Duval, yet a little more than a block off the main area so you can't hear the noise.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Amy, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Lost Shaker of Salt Review

February 2023
, Falls Church, VA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed our stay at Lost Shaker of Salt. It's a beautiful house, with a great outside area and scenic pool, centrally located near everything in Key West, very well maintained, and it came with everything we needed. And the communication with the property manager was outstanding - quick responses and complete information. We hope to book it again.

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Jeffrey! We would love to welcome you back!

Great Location - wonderful home

December 2022
, Merritt Island, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This home is exactly as advertised. We stayed four days and did not get a car. We walked everywhere. For the most part the walking distance is less than a mile to the Key West attractions you will want to see. Uber arrives in two minutes if you elect to Uber. The sunset from Mallory Square is a must do. The house functioned very well for the three adults that were there. The host is easy to reach and very helpful. There were no issues checking in and out. I worked one morning from the back porch over looking the heated pool. The WiFi signal is strong. TVs in all rooms downstairs. Would select this home again. Thank you Shana! We had a wonderful time at your property.

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to post a review of our property Michele. We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed your time in Key West. Our goal is always to exceed your expectations! If there's anything we can help you with during your next visit, please don't hesitate to let us know.

Great location, house, and rental company

December 2022
, Revere, MA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The stay was great. The house was in the middle of everything and you can walk everywhere. The communication from the rental company was also excellent. I would definitely stay here again and recommend it to anyone.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review John. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Great trip!

November 2022
, Waverly, IA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great house and perfect location to Duval St.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this short but sweet five star review Steve, we hope to have the pleasure to host you again next time you visit the island.

Our home away from home

August 2022
, Staten Island, NY United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This was our 5th stay here - we love everything about this house. My favorite is the private yard and pool, and the location can't be beat. Convenient to everything. Sarabeth's is right on the corner and you have a great wine shop on Simonton (UVA Wine). We are already booked for 2023.

Manager's Response

Thank you for sharing a review of your recent experience. Our team here at Best of Key West Rentals is committed to providing high-quality guest service, and we’re thrilled to hear that we keep making a good impression on you. We look forward to welcoming you again next year!

Best Place in Key West

July 2022
, Wellington , FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We have stayed in the house previously and couldn’t wait to return. The second trip did not disappoint. The house is set up perfectly, great private pool, and you can’t beat the location. We will definitely stay here again. The property manager Shana is also helpful and there for your every need.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Charles! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Amazing

May 2022
, Cape Coral , FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect location, great backyard, cozy cottage.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Dean. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

We will definitely stay again!!!!

April 2022
, Pontiac, MI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We throughly enjoyed this property. The booking experience was super easy. The home was larger than we expected. It was very clean. The location was perfect. We could easily get to everything we wanted to do. The property manager was very responsive and helpful. There is no doubt we will rent this house again in the near future.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Jakob! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and look forward to hosting you again in the future!

GrEst place, excellent location

March 2022
, Haleyville, AL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
5

This house was the cutest place! There was 6 of us and we managed great. The pool was beautiful and very private. The proximity to Duvall was perfect as well. The concierce service was great as well. We used it for scooter rentals. The only feedback is parking. You will need to arrange parking, which we did, a couple blocks away. We never needed our vehicle so it wasn’t an issue. We will definitely be back!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Cherie. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Great house and location

March 2022
, Staten Island, NY United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house is clean and perfect for 2 couples. It's located only 2 blocks from Duval. We spent most afternoons in the large private pool and some evenings on the front porch. This is our 3rd time staying here - we'll be back in August. This is our home away from home....

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Kimberly! We look forward to welcoming you back!

Perfect Location

October 2021
, McHenry, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Lost Shaker of Salt was a wonderful rental. The location is perfect - easy walking to everywhere. The home was clean and comfortable for 2 couples. Shana was available any time we needed her. All around wonderful experience!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Cristine, we are thrilled you enjoyed the property so much and hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island!

Great location!

October 2021
, Waxahachie , TX United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The location of this cottage cant be beat. Just 2 blocks from Duval. Check in is a breeze. However,, parking is very difficult. If youre lucky enough to get a spot, guaranteed it wont be there when you return. There are driveways available to some properties but no one is allowed to park in those either. The house is well-decorated and was very clean. Not sure why but there are NO cups or glasses at all in the kitchen...? The beds are fairly comfy and rooms are spacious. Pool is a nice place to cool off. Overall super cute place with only a few improvements needed to make it perfect.

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay Stephanie, we are glad you enjoyed the property. Sorry you missed the kitchen corner cabinet with all the cups, Shana wished you'd let her know so she could have helped you with it. Parking is definitely a challenge for everyone in Key West, most our guests who drive here will leave their car parked for their entire stay and use bikes or scooters to get around. Next time you visit, please let us know you encountered these difficulties and we'll be sure to help you plan a stress free trip!

Great house and amazing location.

July 2021
, Wellington, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

We stayed over a long weekend here and had such an amazing time. You can’t beat the location. We felt close enough to walk to everything but far enough that we felt we could also escape and relax when we wanted. Our only issue was a broken stove/oven but the property manager was great and had it fixed as quickly as she possibly could. I would definitely recommend this house!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We appreciate your understanding in allowing us to fix the oven as soon as possible. We hope to see you again soon!

Great Time

July 2021
, BROKEN ARROW, OK United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Everything about the Lost Shaker was great. Pool was great, location was great, property was very clean and updated! The only suggestion for those booking - the loft sleeping area - very low ceilings so best if used for children.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

Graduation celebration

June 2021
, Goose creek, SC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

This was our 2nd time staying here and we absolutely enjoyed it as much as the 1st time. There were 7 of us, 2 of the boys were 2021 graduates and this trip was for them. The only issue we had was the shower by the kitchen does not have good water pressure or it may just need a stronger shower head. Some things need a little work or maintenance but it was nothing that would keep us from returning! Our stay was not long enough and next time we will be staying longer! Until next time... everything is better in the keys!

Manager's Response

We are so glad your celebratory trip to Key West was a success! We are sorry the downstairs bathroom was a let down, the "rainwater" style shower heads are not meant to have strong pressure, and if someone else in the house was showering at the same time it would probably reduce the pressure some. We are glad to read you plan on staying with us again and look forward to it.

Fantastic Experience!

May 2021
, Cincinnati, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The experience started and ended with Shana and the property management team. The communication relative to check-in, check-out and the property was very helpful. The property was very clean and updated- great location as well!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We hope to see you again soon!

Location location location

April 2021
, Middlesex, NJ United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The location of this rental is almost as good as it gets with its position to duval st. Our group was comfortably accommodated and would absolutely book the same stay again in the future.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We hope to see you again soon!

Perfect Spot!

March 2021
, Staten Island, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

The house was clean and the beds were very comfortable. The location can't be beat - you're in walking distance to everything. The backyard is your own private oasis. It was comfortable for 4 of us -my friend loved the loft. This was our second stay at the house and we can't wait to be back in 2022!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We loved hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you back soon!

Great house, great location

December 2020
, Hinsdale, IL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Our family of four (plus Chihuahua) loved this home! It was clean, the beds were comfortable, had plenty of space, and the pool was warm and inviting! We really enjoyed the privacy and landscaping in the backyard, and drank our coffee out there every morning. You can’t beat the location, so many great restaurants, bars, the beach, and activities were all in walking distance. The property management was great with communication and very friendly. I would definitely rent again if back in Key West!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Super clean Great Location

December 2020
, Pantego, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect house for a getaway. Can’t beat location and parking is very manageable.
Thanks

Manager's Response

Thank you for your recent review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again soon!

Nice house

November 2020
, Thonotosassa, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great place to stay

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review and please come back and see us soon!

Great house!

November 2020
, Hartville, OH United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Very cute house, great location and staff was very professional and great communication. The only down side was the dryer, loud and didn't dry very well. But overall I would defiantly recommend to others and stay there again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We will look into the dryer immediately. Please come back soon!

Beautiful and Very Clean House!

November 2020
, Miami, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was great! only one block away from Duval. Parking wasn't ideal. The only thing missing was at least one reserved parking for the house.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We are so glad you enjoyed this home. The home does not come with a parking spot but should you require one at a later date please let us know in advance.

Wonderful Oasis in a great location

October 2020
, Washington, DC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was wonderful for our group of 4. The house is ideally located near many of the main bars and restaurants of Duval but is also nicely tucked away from the noisy streets and crowds. Check in was easy, the house was beautiful and clean and the pool area was a wonderful place to unwind or prepare for the day's adventures. Finally our property manager, Shana, was highly responsive and helpful, she made the entire check in and check out process a breeze. Overall I highly recommend this property for groups of 4-6!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

A great place to stay

August 2020
, Norfolk, NE US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
5

It was clean upon arrival, great to hang out after a long day adventuring key west, great walking distance to duvall street and Mallory Square!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your 5 star review. We hope to host you again soon!

Family Vacation

July 2020
, Lynn Haven, Florida United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Stayed with our family of 8 - included father and sister in law. The home sleeps 8 but the sofa bed is in the open kitchen area and can get loud at night, so that area would be best for kiddos or whoever stays up the latest! The loft area with the twin beds is an open area and is probably better suited for kids - our teenage boys loved it up there. We loved this home, especially the private pool area in the backyard which was perfect for the hot days and nights. It was within walking distance to all we wanted to see and do (Cuban Coffee Queen is one block away) and would absolutely stay here again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to be able to host you again soon.

Family Vacation

July 2020
, Lynn Haven, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Stayed with our family of 8 - included father and sister in law. The home sleeps 8 but the sofa bed is in the open kitchen area and can get loud at night, so that area would be best for kiddos or whoever stays up the latest! The loft area with the twin beds is an open area and is probably better suited for kids - our teenage boys loved it up there. We loved this home, especially the private pool area in the backyard which was perfect for the hot days and nights. It was within walking distance to all we wanted to see and do (Cuban Coffee Queen is one block away) and would absolutely stay here again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to be able to host you again soon.

Great getaway

June 2020
, Miami, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was quaint and clean. Enjoyed our stay. The pool was a great additio. Customer service was beyond excellent. Can’t wait to stay there again:)

Manager's Response

Thank you for the wonderful review. We are so glad to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you soon.

Great getaway

June 2020
, Miami, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was quaint and clean. Enjoyed our stay. The pool was a great additio. Customer service was beyond excellent. Can’t wait to stay there again:)

Manager's Response

Thank you for the wonderful review. We are so glad to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you soon.

Great stay

December 2019
, Hermitage, TN United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great location. The rental company was so wonderful to work with—very fast responding for our last minute stay. Would definitely rent from this company in the future

Manager's Response

Dear Sheila,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you back soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great House in Key West

November 2019
, Miami Shores, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
4
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Loved the house -even better in person than in the images-great location to walk anywhere -close enough to Duval -but just removed enough to explore other neighborhoods off the main drag. Perfect for small group of 4 but can also be good for up to 6. Dog friendly was a huge bonus so we could travel with our pups!

Manager's Response

Dear Vicky,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy you loved this home and we hope to be able to host you again soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Absolutely fantastic!

November 2019
, NA, NA NA

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Our family of 7 spent Thanksgiving in this charming house and it was just perfect! You can't beat the location - a block & a half off Duval - super quite street. The house was clean, bed were comfortable and the pool was perfection. Highly recommend this house & the Best of Key West Rental company.

Manager's Response

Dear Erinn,


Thank you for your incredible review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you back again!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

60th Birthday Celebration

November 2019
, Elk Grove Village, IL US

Overall
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

What is not to like about the "Lost Shaker of Salt"? My friends and I really enjoyed our 4 night stay. Perfect size for 5 adults, great location to all the bars and restaurants on Duval St., rental was very clean and the pool was excellent. Management team was on top their game. Highly recommend this rental property.

Manager's Response

Dear Tom,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed your stay at this home. We hope to see you back again soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

One of the best rentals I’ve ever stayed at

October 2019
, Liberty township, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Not only is this property just beautiful and perfect, it is incredible in location. 2 blocks from the middle of Duval and has a very private pool.. this is unheard of in key west. We only had to take Uber’s to and from the airport, we were able to walk literally everywhere else. The property managers went above and beyond to work with us and offered concierge services for anything and everything you could think of on the island. We will definitely be booking again here!

Manager's Response

Dear Lee-Anne,


WOW! Thank you for your incredible feedback. We are so happy that you loved this rental home and hope to see you back again soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Lost Shaker of Salt

October 2019
, Palm Harbor, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Home was everything we expected. Great location, clean, comfortable and private.

Manager's Response

Dear Deanna,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you back again soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great place! Perfect location and was everything we wanted!

September 2019
, Charleston, SC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This house is so cute and is a perfect location from Duval street and all the great sites of Key West. The concierge service was helpful and accommodating. The pool is private and such a great place to spend time with friends. The beds were comfortable and the bathrooms were spacious. There are pool towels and a couple pool floats there. Easy to get downtown and parking for the golf cart we rented was on the street. Several keys available for our group. Definitely recommend this place for any one wanting to be in the heart of Key West and close to everything.

Manager's Response

Dear Amanda,


Thank you for your wonderful review on Lost Shaker of Salt. We are so thrilled to hear how perfect your vacation was at this home and we hope to see you back soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Beautiful place in great location

September 2019
, Saint augustine, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Clean, great location, good communication ,
Thank you!

Manager's Response

Dear Oliver,


Thank you for your incredible review! We are so thrilled you had such a wonderful time and we hope to see you back soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great loction, great house!

July 2019
, tavares, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

It was perfect. Love the house, pool, amenities, the location could not have been better!

Manager's Response

Dear Vincent,


Thank you for your kind words on your recent stay in Paradise. We are so thrilled you had such a wonderful time in this home and we hope to see you back very soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Perfect...for us

July 2019
, Grasonville, MD United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

The property had every amenity necessary and was walking distance to everything...including a grocery store. We never drove. The pool was a huge hit, especially in July. The room upstairs is very small (I couldn't stand up), but it was ok for the younger girls. Also, the property manager Brian was very thorough and responded to all questions immediately.

Manager's Response

Dear John,


Thank you for your wonderful review on Lost Shaker of Salt! We are thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed your time in Paradise and we hope to see you back soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

A very nice place and a great time in Key West.

April 2019
, Hazelwood, MO US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

We had a great time at our annual guys' trip at the Lost Shaker of Salt. It's a great little place and was just perfect for our long weekend. In walking distance to everything and though small it never felt like the 5 of us were in each other's way. And the backyard oasis made for a great place to relax and be away from the

Manager's Response

Dear Hans,


Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review. We are so thrilled that your annual guys trip was such a success at this incredible Key West home. The location is truly unbeatable and the pool is a great amenity. Thank you for being our guest and please come back and see us soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Perfect location

March 2019
, Mendham, NJ US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

my two teen daughters and my husband and I thought this house was the perfect size and location for our trip. We walked to everything.

Manager's Response

Dear Meredith,


Thank you for the review you provided on your recent stay at Lost Shaker of Salt. We are so happy to hear that this home was perfect in size and location for your family. You really don't need a vehicle when visiting this incredible home since it is located just walking distance to many great restaurants as well as Duval St. Thank you for being our guest and please come back and see us soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Relaxation

March 2019
, Miami Beach, FL US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
3

Great location, pool was very private and was great to open the back sliding doors, but some furnishing starting to show their age

Manager's Response

Dear Robert,


Thank you for your feedback on your recent stay at Lost Shaker of Salt. We are so happy to hear how much you loved the Old Town location and the indoor/outdoor space of this incredible home. We loved having you as our guest and hope to see you again next year!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

5 stars. Perfect place!

November 2018

Overall
5

Beautiful place. Loved the convenience of the location. Pool was perfect to come back to when we had been in our boat to get the salt water off. The house accomadatted our group perfectly. And the gas grill came in handy for out steak dinner! Thank you for the great experience renting a home in key west

Fantastic, decorated nicely, furnished with everything you could possibly need

October 2018

Overall
5

Everything was perfect. The Zintmaster team was excellent with communication. The house was clean, beautifully furnished and stocked with everything we didn't know we would need!

Great!

September 2018

Overall
5

Best family vacation ever!!! House was beautiful and in the perfect location off Deval St. I wouldnt have wanted to spend my 60th bday any other way. Thanks for the memories..

Excellent location and facility!

August 2018

Overall
5

Excellent!!!

Fun in the sun!

May 2018

Overall
5

This house is very clean, nice outdoor area with pool, and great location to Duvall Street.